T.J. Watt became the highest-paid non-quarterback in NFL history when he inked a record-breaking three-year, $123 million contract extension with the Pittsburgh Steelers.

While Watt is putting together a Hall-of-Fame worthy resume, the one thing he is lacking is any sort of postseason success. Watt’s singular brilliance has helped keep the Steelers competitive during his tenure, Pittsburgh is winless in the postseason with Watt in the lineup, most of them losses in which the defense has struggled.